23: v Arsenal 2014/15
This goal is the only penalty he has scored for the club. Again this was towards the end of the 2014/15 season and with Gerrard on the bench Henderson was on captain and penalty duties. Liverpool were 3-0 down in this game at the Emirates before he tucked away this penalty.
Hector Bellerin, Mesut Ozil and Alexis Sanchez had given the Gunners an unassailable lead. Then in the 75th minute Bellerin brought down Raheem Sterling in the area for a penalty. Henderson put a soft penalty to the keepers right. David Ospina almost got a pal to it after guessing the right way. Luckily for Henderson it was just far and fast enough to evade his outstretched arm.
Any hope for Liverpool was short lived as Emre Can was sent off less than 10 minutes later for a second yellow and his first red card for the club. Oliver Giroud topped the victory a minute later by scoring to make for a 4-1 loss and a forgettable day for Reds fans.